As A Rangers Fan, I Share In Your Disappointment

As A Rangers Fan, You Have My Respect Islanders

Across Long Island and the country, New York Islanders fans are waking up this morning with a sense of disappointment. I would imagine New York Rangers fans are waking up this morning with a sense of happiness and joy knowing that their long-time hockey rival has been eliminated from Stanley Cup contention. But for me, as a New York Rangers fan, I feel no happiness at all, I share in some of the disappointment that Islanders fans are feeling. Islanders fans have no reason to be disappointed in their team; the Islanders played every round of the playoffs with grit, determination, and passion. Islanders fans should hold their heads up high this morning, proud of their team’s accomplishments.

So why do I as a New York Rangers fan feel disappointed for Islanders fans? It started in the 90s when I was a teenager. My entire family, two sisters, father and uncle were all New York Islanders fans, but my older cousin Bobby, who was like a brother / father figure was a die-hard Rangers fan. I looked up to him and wanted to be like him as he was very influential on who I have become as an adult. So, it was natural that I would root for his team, as it connected us more and one year he gave me a New York Rangers quiz, in which the prize for passing was a #18 Tony Granato Jersey. That may not seem like much, but to me that jersey was the world. In 1994 when the Rangers won the Stanley Cup, my cousin was a season ticket holder who got to witness the win in person at Madison Square Garden, and although it was 26 years ago, I will never forget the sound of excitement and emotion in his voice when he called me up shortly after that win.  In that moment I felt as though I was part of something amazing and historic.

As I got older, while in college I worked night security at the Long Island Marriott, next door to the Coliseum. I would get to deal with all the rowdy, intoxicated fans who would come to the bar before and after the game. I have vague memories of a guy who had a golden streamer style wig, who was always a huge, passionate fan, almost like a mascot or cheerleader for the team. I was lucky to meet a lot of players from various teams in the league who would stay with us, including Jeremy Roenick who put a $100 bill in my jacket pocket as an apology for making too much noise. In his first season with the team, I had the pleasure to meet Bryan Berard, as his dad locked his keys in his car, and I had to slim jim the door to unlock them. As a thank you, Bryan invited me to come watch a game, seated with his family. 

In 2012, I received an invitation from the Islanders Senior Vice President to come to headquarters and educate their marketing team on how to effectively send email marketing / campaigns. It was great to visit and meet some of the business personnel and share my professional skills and expertise with the team to stay in communication with their fans.

As years went by, my family welcomed the birth of my four nephews, born from passionate die-hard Islanders mothers. As my nephews grew up, one of them, Jeremy, became Islanders obsessed, his bedroom a shrine to the team that would rival the team’s official Pro Shop. He would even go on to play junior hockey. He was a kid that would stand outside the Nassau Coliseum with his blue and orange mohawk just waiting for players to come out, so he could get a quick hello, autograph, or photo.

Outside of the holiday get-togethers, the only time I spent with my family was going to a few Islanders games, and it was fun to watch them all dressed up in their blue and orange banging on the glass behind the players benches yelling and screaming. I have several memories going to games with my dad and my uncle John. At another game my family attended, one of my other nephews Lucas got to sing with his school during one of the intermissions.

A few years ago, Jeremy set up a lemonade stand outside his house with some of the local kids to raise money for the Matt Martin Foundation. Jeremy had met Matt a bunch of times over the years and always looked up to him as a player. When Matt heard about Jeremy’s lemonade stand, although he had just been sent to play for Toronto, he drove all the way out to my nephew’s house to visit the lemonade stand, meet some of the kids and spent a great deal of his personal time just hanging out, talking with the kids, taking photos and signing autographs. Football has always been my primary passion sport, but hockey players are above and beyond the best type of people.

It goes without saying, that 2020 has been a year filled with uncertainty, chaos and a sense of unknown. The climate of our country’s pulse and sense of togetherness feels like it has never been further apart. Civil injustice and unrest have been at the forefront of the news and has been present in many of our professional sports games as athletes are standing together, in unity to bring positive change.

Having hockey playoffs resume, finally felt like the beginning of a return to normalcy, something we could all watch and enjoy as only a few short months ago, it was very possible there would be no conclusion to this season. It’s amazing to think we are in mid-September and this time last year, I was getting ready to take a vacation with my dad to Las Vegas (the first time we ever traveled together), catching a Golden Knights pre-season game (something everyone should have on their bucket list). With the Rangers early departure from the playoffs, I was closely following both the Vegas Golden Knights and the New York Islanders. The Golden Knights, because meeting and talking with their fans and seeing how much that city rallies together was unlike anything I have witnessed in sports. The Islanders because I wanted my family and nephews see their team continue to progress.

"If there’s hope for Rangers fans and Islanders fans coming together, maybe there’s a little bit of hope for the rest of the country."

Along the way, throughout the playoffs I began to connect with several Islanders fans on Twitter, perhaps the most passionate one being Donnie, Owner of Blue Line Deli & Bagels in Huntington. Donnie has found a way to combine his deli / bagel business with his passion and love for the Islanders and it was great to see someone who gave back so much to the fans of the team. I first heard about Donnie’s deli from Peter Schwartz, who lives in Nassau and drives to Huntington for bagels, that says a lot about someone’s character that people would drive 20-30 minutes for a bagel and coffee.

So I was in for this playoff run, supporting the Islanders, which to say as a Rangers fan seems odd. I even had a few people on Twitter call me a sellout with no allegiance to my team. The truth however is, I have been rooting for the Islanders to make it to the end, for one simple reason… my family and the people I have been able to connect with over the past few weeks. The Islanders / Rangers rivalry is one of the biggest in all professional sports, it sits along side the likes of the Yankees / Red Sox, The Lakers / Celtics and the Dallas Cowboys / Any team playing the Dallas Cowboys. But historically there has been a hatred between Rangers and Islanders fans, to the point attending games could be outright violent at times.

For me, the rivalry between Islanders and Rangers fans kind of mirrors what is going on in the country today. People are divided instead of united; people are fighting and being hateful towards one another instead of embracing differences and coming together. I realize it may be a reach to compare sports fans with the problems facing our country, but as I think about being able to witness my Seattle Seahawks win their first Super Bowl, I think about the fact that my cousin Bobby, a lifelong Rams fan from their first time in Los Angeles was standing right beside me. The Seahawks / Rams are heated football rivals and there in the biggest moment of celebration I have experienced in sports, was my rival, rooting not for my team but for me to experience the happiness and joy that he had 20 years earlier at Madison Square Garden.

If there’s hope for Rangers fans and Islanders fans coming together, maybe there’s a little bit of hope for the rest of the country.

Last night was a tough game, even the final goal felt anti-climactic. I woke up this morning feeling a little disappointed, not because the team is no longer in the playoffs but because the hope for fans like my nephew Jeremy, Peter Schwartz or Donnie down at Blue Line has ended for 2020.

Rangers fans are to Islanders fans what Thanos is to Ironman, so to paraphrase a quote from the movie, Islanders fans… “You have my respect!”

Share Your Comments Below

Brian D. Oakes

Brian D. Oakes

Simple, Clean, Originally Unique Creative Artistic Designs I've been a professional designer for over 20 years. I have a huge passion for architecture and sports and love to incorporate both of those into my designs.
Homepage Promo

24 HOUR FLASH SALE

50% OFF WALL ART

USE CODE "SPRING" AT CHECKOUT

OFFER ENDS IN

Hours
Minutes
Seconds